I might seem biased as a Zionsville resident, but I swear I'd drive from out of town for this place! Fresh, New York style slices ready to pop in the oven for a quick crisp up. So many choices too! The BBQ chicken is so yum, the meat is lightly breaded so it really sops up the tangy BBQ sauce. The pepperoni slice is always a no brainer, like something off a street cart in the big city. But for me, if I have a few extra minutes, it's hard to resist their rice ball. It's rice, cheese, peas, and meat mixed into a nice sized ball and deep fried. It's served on a dollop of warm ricotta and topped with marinara. It doesn't sound all that delicious, the peas might be throwing you off here, but it is outta this world! I can't emphasize this enough- I wanna grab you by the lapels and shake you, saying "listen to me. Listen-to-me! This rice ball thing is a money shot!" Oh and by the way, they also have red cream soda from the fountain so BOOM-deal sealed. (Short of five stars only due to much needed bathroom remodel and ho hum interior.)

I wish I was in this neck of the woods more often. As a fellow Italiano, you don't get more authentic than this. I get a different flavor slice each time and always a side of Italian sausage and peppers. Impressed every time and the service is impeccable!

Save

Save

Absolutely love this place. It's like a Panera bread but with Italian. Everything is fresh, fast, and authentic. The lunch prices are awesome. My favorite quick Italian food!

My team at work went to Amore for a group lunch and had an awesome experience.

We called ahead to let them know 14 people would be coming and while they didn't take reservations he said that if we arrived before 11:30 we would be just fine. When we got there he indicated we could sit wherever and move tables or chairs as needed. When we were ready we all lined up and ordered. They were super fast and efficient. The lunch specials are great. You can choose 2 slices, and a drink, or a slice and 2 breadsticks, and a drink etc all very reasonably priced. The awesome part of the lunch specials is that you could pick any slice. Not just cheese or pepperoni, any slice, specialty pies and all.

They also offer catering so if you are on the Northwest Side or in Zionsville area I would definitely recommend contacting Amore Pizzeria!

Great local pizza. Love the way the display and cook their pizza, makes the decision process easier for everyone. Food is always good. One of our favorite pizza places in Indianapolis.