WHAT OUR FANS SAY
12/22/2020 – Matt D., Whitestown
New York style pizza in Zionsville. Pizza is solid (though I usually just get a bunch of meatballs – they’re tasty), but for me the real draw is the community spirit. Amore has been here for ages. In the last couple of years, their outreach and support of the community has been amazing. Good pizza. Great support of local schools and events. Personal touches in store and for delivery. This is the definition of a local pizza joint and worth supporting with my business.
3/23/2020 – Elizabeth R., Zionsville, IN
Always so fast and great for quick dinners, dine in or carry out. The garlic knots are to die for and the calzones and pizzas are amazing! They have the best marinara sauce too! Would definitely recommend, for both family dinners and parties!
10/4/2020 – Jennifer W., Zionsville, IN
Amore is our favorite place for pizza in Zionsville! Their garlic knots are heaven. Get their Alfredo to dip them in! Make sure to sign up for text alerts and you can also get discount codes!
11/19/2019 – Jim C., Carmel, IN
If you are in Zionsville and craving pizza, Amore’s is the place to go. It’s located in a strip center on the north side of Oak Street and by a Kroger Grocery.
We like the Meat Lovers Pizza with traditional crust. It comes loaded with double pepperoni, sausage, bacon and ham. We omit the bacon and add Italian Sausage. It is delicious and one or two pieces alone is very filling! A 14″ small is $17.99, a 16″ medium is $20.99, and a 18″ large is $23.99. You can find coupons for Amore’s in the Value Pak that comes in the mail.
We also like the Antipasto Salad and Bread Sticks with cheese dip. And, you can buy pizza by the slice.
You order at the counter and then they either deliver it to your table or you can pick it up at the counter. The servers are friendly, the ingredients are fresh and the food is hot.
8/12/2019 – Sandra M., Indianapolis, IN
This is the ONLY place for pizza in Indiana. My family and I have been coming here a long time. We stopped coming because we started a Keto lifestyle. Out of frustration, I called them and asked if they had a Keto option. They said they have a crust made of cheese and cauliflower. We came right over. This is the BEST pizza. It is worth the drive if you are not close. This rivals any regular pizza. Trust me- I have tried them and nothing compares to this. Amore was my happy place before and now it is again.
10/16/2020 – John T., Whitestown, IN
Great pizza stop in Zionsville. Many choices but I particularly like the barbecue chicken pizza. Big slices and choice of a soft drink if you buy two slices. In these times, I get my slices “to go,” but their dining room is old style pizza parlor and accomodating. Staff is friendly.
10/23/2020 – Amanda R., Manhattan, New York, NY
Having just moved back to Indy from NYC, we’ve been on the hunt for an east coast pizza spot. So excited to find AMORE. We ordered the classic 18 in pepperoni pizza and a meatball sub, both delicious and coming from the Big Apple, reasonably priced. Thrilled to see they also offered black and white cookies, another nyc staple. Staff was very helpful and friendly. Tip: sign up for text messages to receive discount offers.
7/19/2020 – Scott L., Victorville, CA
First class operation through and through. From the second we walked in the door everything was top notch. The pizza is simply the best you’ll find in Indiana.
11/29/2020 – Alex M., Sandy Springs, GA
Fantastic pizza and customer service. A must try if you are looking for delicious NY-style pizza!
12/15/2019 – Denise P., Indianapolis, IN
My favorite night of the week. Sunday night lasagna. They make the best lasagna. Thick, meaty sauce that tastes like it has simmered all day, lots of layers with cheese goodness (but not too much), and enough for left overs. My husband likes the firehouse lasagna. Has a spicy sausage kick and mushrooms. Get it with a Cesar salad and pepperoni breadsticks. Definitely homemade goodness. And the pizza is really great too! We never make it past the lasagna, though.
8/27/2020 – Carol D., Lebanon, IN
I ate in with my friend who raved about this place! I was not disappointed. Everyone there was very nice, the staff were very busy but still gracious. I ordered the two slices of pizza and a drink lunch. It was delicious and mouth watering ingredients I wanted to try all of the varieties they had available. I chose a Margarita and a Hawaiian. Each had quality mozzarella on a thin crust, but the Hawaiian was the best with loads of ham and chunks of pineapple on it. I can’t wait to return for more!!
5/31/2020 – Chris S. McKinney, TX
I will start by saying we are primarily a Chicago style deep dish family. I’ve had pizza in New York a few times and was never really impressed. But Amore pizza is fantastic. We’ve had both the regular crust and Sicilian style and they are both great. Good sauce, fresh cheese, amazing sausage. A word of caution: order early or plan ahead on the weekends, they get busy!
11/1/2020 – Cherie R. Indianapolis, IN
This was our first visit to Amore. The young man behind the counter was very helpful in helping us decide. He was so proud of the food offered, very knowledgeable and efficient. We will definitely be back.know is how that food changed and flourished when New York was blessed with our people.
New York Italian food, and especially pizza, is a world of its own.
The style of cooking that came out of NYC in the early part of this century is some of the best cooking in the world. We use our knowledge of our family culture and recipes to bring what we can to our new home here in Zionsville.
Dedicated to consistency, unmatched customer service, and community involvement… while at Amore, you will FEEL THE LOVE!!!